Senate Considers Nomination of Sharon Block to the NLRB

UPDATE: On September 17, 2014, the Senate HELP Committee voted 13-9 along party lines to advance Sharon Block's nomination.

A day after the Senate returned from its summer recess, the Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions held a hearing to discuss the nomination of former recess appointee Sharon Block to be a member of the National Labor Relations Board. President Obama announced his intent to re-nominate Block to the Board on July 10, 2014. Block previously served as a member of the Board from January 2012 – when the President seated her and two other members via recess appointment – until the summer of 2013, when her nomination was withdrawn as part of a Senate deal to allow votes on the five current NLRB members.  In June of this year, the U.S. Supreme Court in Noel Canning held that Block's recess appointment was invalid.  

During the hearing, several lawmakers questioned the appropriateness of re-seating a member whose prior term was held unconstitutional.  Senator Lamar Alexander (R-TN) noted that there are 436 NLRB decisions that were issued between January 2012 and July 2013 that are no longer good law and must be re-decided.  He questioned Block's ability to be impartial should she be involved in that reconsideration process, as he claimed she has "demonstrated a willingness to tilt the playing field in favor of organized labor." 

Block evaded several questions about specific cases and regulatory activity, including the pending changes to election rules and Excelsior list information, organizing student athletes, the Board's 2012 decision in Fresenius USA Manufacturing, Inc. and International Brotherhood of Teamsters, and the propriety of the NLRB General Counsel taking a position on joint employment when a Board case on this very issue is still pending. Block claimed that since she might be confirmed to the Board, it would not be appropriate to weigh in on these issues at this time. 

Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-UT) asked Block whether she planned to recuse herself from cases she participated in that now must be reconsidered. Block responded that "if a party were to make a request to recuse, I would take that request seriously." In addition, she said she would consult with the agency's ethics officials to determine whether recusal was necessary. She noted that the deliberation process would be different, as she would be working with new colleagues this time around should she be confirmed.  

Sen. Tim Scott (R-SC) focused his inquiry on the Board's finding in Karl Knauz Motors, Inc. that an employer's "courtesy" rule was overbroad and thus violated the NLRA. Scott asked how such a rule could possibly be inappropriate, and found fault with what he perceived as a "lack of equilibrium" on the Board.  Block responded that the Board is often faced with "competing interests," and tries to "draw a line" between policies that seek professionalism and decorum and those that could be seen as limiting an employee's ability to "speak frankly and honestly about their working conditions."    

While the Board is operating at full capacity, Member Nancy Schiffer's (D) term is set to end on December 16, 2014.  Therefore, a vote on Block's nomination is expected to take place before then. 

Meanwhile, Sen. Alexander announced that next week he and Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-KY) would introduce legislation "to restore the NLRB to its original purpose," which is to "act as an umpire instead of an advocate."  

An archived webcast of the hearing can be found here.

Information contained in this publication is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or opinion, nor is it a substitute for the professional judgment of an attorney.